Carney Insurance
(719) 284-7294 — Colorado Springs(651) 464-6001 — Forest Lake
Client Login
Our Story

Three Generations of Doing Insurance Right

80+ years of combined experience. 70+ companies. Two states. One mission: get you the right coverage at the best price.

Who We Are

Independent. Local. Family-Owned.

Carney Insurance has been serving Colorado and Minnesota families and businesses for generations. We're a third-generation independent agency. Which means we work for you, not for an insurance company.

As a local agency, we have a deep understanding of Colorado and its unique areas and their specific insurance requirements. From hail season on the Front Range to wildfire risk in the foothills, we know what matters here.

We represent 70+ top-rated insurance companies, which lets us shop the market and find you the best rate. Not just the one we're assigned to sell.

Our Values

How We Work

Transparency

No fine print surprises. We explain what you're buying and what it does. And doesn't. Cover.

Advocacy

When a claim goes sideways, we get involved. You're not alone in dealing with the carrier.

Independence

We're not captive to any one company. Our loyalty is to you, the client.

Longevity

Three generations means we're not going anywhere. Your kids can work with us too.